Soon the tribe consisted of a total of five eliminated contestants.
After making a surprise entry in the game, the two returnees are not very warmly welcomed by their ex-tribe mates.
Shilpa and Michael, being immune, were safe from the outcome of the next immunity challenge which Tayak ended by losing and facing tribal council for the fourth time in a row.
Catan's inaugural victory in the reward challenge caused them to underestimate their opposing tribe's mettle.
At the first tribal council faced by the Catan tribe, Sylvie was blindsided by her fellow mates and was voted off.
From that point on, the outcasts who were vote out of the game, formed a new tribe on the island of Ayunan with the same name.